Are the Changguan Really That Bad?

Are the Changguan Really That Bad?
chamaflauge Sep 12, 2013 10:49

I have been living in the same apartment complex and neighborhood for over four years now.  Despite the degradation of apartment, the complex, and neighborhood; prices have continued to rise. For example, when I first arrived in this neighborhood, the streets were clean and it was a relatively quiet place to almost rival that of the French Concession (I shouldn’t exaggerate too much).

 

After the second year things started to take a weird turn. The streets were suddenly dirtier with litter, saliva, and other unsightly things. The real-estate places started closing down, and yet another hair salon opened up; blaring its loud music including feminine lady boys hanging outside (There are around five on one block alone).

 

By year three the unsightly began to appear. You know your neighborhood has gone to shit when the street crazies start to arrive.  If you are wondering who they are; these are the people who will kill fish and cut a chicken’s throat, and then let the blood run in the streets. If you are walking by it is quite nauseating; especially if you are walking around with children. Then there are the vegetable venders who will park themselves right outside your gate.

 

After they are finished they throw rotten vegetables everywhere that leave a stench. You have to wonder do these people wash their hands after handling your food.  I ask this because I notice that at least 50% of business men don’t wash their hands after peeing or pooping. Half the time there isn’t even any soap around. So if you cannot even trust a business man, how can you trust a street vender who is less educated, less well off, cares less about hygiene, and has less access to a bathroom?

 

Then there are the beggars who can smell money from miles away and arrive in droves. Epileptics miraculously arrive in chairs with no wheels. Legless vagabonds are inching their way towards your feet. It is a wonder how one can get to work with all the clutter that blocks the walkway. It reminds me of the walking dead.

 

These past few months I have noticed that the Changguan have arrived and I have seen how they work. They usually arrive on the scene at the early morning or evening. Everyone scatters like roaches for about 15 minutes, and once the Changguan are gone everyone returns and gets back to business. While others detest them I cheer when they arrive. Everyone looks at me like if I am stupid.

 

It leaves me to wonder why we give the Changguan such a bad name. I think of them as the gunslingers of the West. Here to rescue us from oblivion, pollution and living in squalor. They are the messengers, so why do we wish to kill them? Sure there are many outlaws that crave on power and doing harm to society, but most are doing their jobs.

 

Chinese netizens seem to think that these people do great harm to society. They seem to think that the street crazies are the victims. I frequently hear….

“These people are trying to earn a living. At least they are not stealing and killing”

This is a silly rationalization. Should we applaud a person simply because he wishes not to steal and kill? Should we be grateful that the crazy has found a job to do?

 

I say…if you cannot afford to live in Shanghai then do not come. There are too many people here to begin with. The last unofficial estimate was 27 million.  This is bigger than most countries. This is due to the government not expanding to 3rd tier cities. If you have to resort to selling things on the street, maybe the big city is not a right fit for you

 

See I wouldn’t have a problem with it if the crazies didn’t pollute the environment.

 

If the vegetable vender cleaned up after his mess

If the crazy who killed fish and chickens could cover up his genocide

If the vagabond didn’t hound and pester you as if you owe him a life

If the barbershop could turn down the ridiculous music

 

But these people make it hard to sympathize with them. Well except maybe for the disabled beggar. This is mafia problem. I'm sure that the beggar industry is in the multi millions of dollars in Shanghai, Beijing , Guangzhou, and Shenzhen. Some organizations even sending their beggars to other countries.

 

I really detest seeing scoundrels outside of my apartment complex.

 

I know I may sound harsh but for the prices I pay for my current apartment I expect results.

Don’t you?

Tags:General Health & Environment Relationships Teaching & Learning Business & Jobs Food Language & Culture Expat Rants & Advice Expat Tales Lifestyle

9 Comments

All comments are subject to moderation by eChinacities.com staff. Because we wish to encourage healthy and productive dialogue we ask that all comments remain polite, free of profanity or name calling, and relevant to the original post and subsequent discussion. Comments will not be deleted because of the viewpoints they express, only if the mode of expression itself is inappropriate. Please use the Classifieds to advertise your business and unrelated posts made merely to advertise a company or service will be deleted.

Guest487398

welcome to china, If you do not like it, just leave go back to getto where you are from, you have to change your mind if not you will not survive here. have ,good night,

Sep 18, 2013 22:44 Report Abuse

Guest126504

Do something useful. Rally all the people in the compound to take the street back. Whine your problems here do not solve a thing.

Sep 17, 2013 04:14 Report Abuse

donkey

the problem is that they are corrupt beyond anything. In general any country needs people who enforce hygine, construction laws etc. But the Chengguan is not there to enforce rules. They are there to collect bribes.

Sep 16, 2013 22:26 Report Abuse

Corflamum

In some ways, I really do see your point. Chengguan (it is cheng with an 'e') are like garbagemen--they provide a service nobody wants to do and are constantly fighting a losing battle. You tell someone to quit smoking inside, you literally turn your back and he starts again. I can understand why you might start busting heads over something as simple as a street vendor with a watermelon cart. You tell a man to move and he says what are you going to do about it... that being said, the system is terribly broken. There is virtually no way to enforce any law on the books (when people can agree what those laws even are) except your extralegal powers. I'm not defending the horrible things they have done and continue to do unhindered. Just having worked in a call center for many years, I have a soft spot for people who have shit jobs where you can't win no matter what you do.

Sep 15, 2013 11:48 Report Abuse

expatlife26

Like you i just wonder if it's really advantageous for them to be in the first tier cities...for their sake as well as ours. Maybe they can make a little more but they have to be constantly reminded of their place at the bottom. At least in their village they have family, social connections etc with people who don't treat them like scumbags, fair or not. I dunno, maybe it really is impossible to survive out there. I'm picturing it as being a situation where they could maybe make 1000 per month in their hometowns and 1400 here, but maybe it's be hear or make nothing and starve. I really dunno.

Sep 17, 2013 10:15 Report Abuse

profenieto

Your arguments may seen cruel but are true. You made a great analysis of the reality!

Sep 15, 2013 01:04 Report Abuse

expatlife26

Great blog Chamaflauge! I agree with all of your points, I think the Changguan get a really bad rap but honestly they ARE enforcing laws (though maybe not in an honest way). The people whose things they confiscate and stalls they smash are breaking the law! Yeah they are corrupt scumbags in some way, but they can't extort protection money from someone who is behaving legally, the person that has to bribe them must be themselves breaking the law so they are not so innocent. Should they be permitted to break the law just because they are poor? There isn't a clear good and bad guy in the clash of illegal street vendors vs. chengguan. And yes the vendors are very irresponsible towards the public environment and towards life in general. I think a responsible person can live respectably at any income level. Being poor might mean a very small home, it might mean cheap materials...but it only means dirty because a person doesn't bother to clean up and when these people bring their poor values to respectable neighborhoods the quality of life suffers for everyone. Even the people themselves have to live like shit while seeing the modern things they can't afford, not fun for anyone.

Sep 13, 2013 14:40 Report Abuse

expatlife26

Yeah...I guess it's human nature to always try to find the good and bad guy in every situation. The street vendors aren't these wonderful angels bravely standing up for their rights and the chengguan aren't just jackbooted thugs picking on law abiding citizens. It's rarely that simple. I look at it like this, these street vendors feel entitled to the privilege of getting to operate a business FOR FREE on public property with absolutely zero overhead, taxes or regulation which undercuts restaurants who pay rent, pay taxes and are at least subject to some sort of hygiene inspection. Why do they feel entitled to this? It's pretty unreasonable when you think about it. In general I think it's really hard for people who have very little to understand just how much work goes into making something *nice*. A nice neighborhood isn't nice because of a magic spell cast by the presence of "rich people", it's nice specifically because there aren't people there making it dirty, and when a mess is made it's cleaned up. You take beverly hills and fill it with people who don't care and it'll be stop being nice pretty quick.

Sep 17, 2013 09:40 Report Abuse

quill

Chengguan are idiomatic of a broken system. To your eyes, they achieve results, but they do this at a great cost: as the law, they are lawless. There are literally hundreds of bad stories about chengguan. The latest I saw was a video were these chengguan were trying to extort "protection money" from a water products seller. Protection from themselves. In short: "Who chengguan's the chengguan?"

Sep 13, 2013 11:00 Report Abuse